Pokazywanie postów oznaczonych etykietą humanities. Pokaż wszystkie posty
Pokazywanie postów oznaczonych etykietą humanities. Pokaż wszystkie posty

wtorek, 14 kwietnia 2015

Impressions from The 61st Annual Meeting of the RSA in Berlin, March 26–28, 2015. Part 2: Politics (wersja polska poniżej)

I wrote here before about contemporary politics vs. academic study in the field of early modern culture. It strikes me every now and then how often these seemingly distant areas intertwine. Recent Annual Meeting of the Renaissance Society of America supplied me with some new examples of this phenomenon.

One of them was the exhibition named ‘Das verschwundene Museum’ (The Lost Museum) officially accompanying the conference and displayed in the Bode Museum where the opening reception took place. Here Germany’s war losses were presented, together with issues of conservation and retribution of the artworks. This can obviously be considered as an example of modern-day German politics of memory, or at least of one of its currents – one focused on presenting the German nation as victims of war, without necessarily stressing their role in starting it. As such, the exhibition was not taken well by some of my Polish colleagues. While I agree that the chosen topic was not politically neutral, I do not sympathize with some of the opinions I heard during the reception which can be summarized as follows: ‘I don’t pity Germany neither for their lost artworks, nor for their civilian victims of war, as Germans did the same to us’. I couldn’t agree less. I am strongly against destroying any works of art, anywhere, as they all belong to common heritage of mankind. I am strongly against killing civilian population on purpose, anywhere and of any nation. I also expressed these opinions openly to my colleagues during the reception, being only surprised how quickly we switched to this quite heated exchange from discussing our studies on early modern era.
 
‘Das verschwundene Museum’ - exhibition poster
The issue of politics in renaissance studies came back in yet another form on the final day of the conference. A statement of junior members of the RSA was read aloud by professor Lisa Jardine. The anonymous authors expressed their concern that in the recent years only two women were invited to hold a key-note speech on the meeting. While the male-female disproportion was evident, reasons for it, in my opinion, may vary. For instance, in the earlier generations more men than women pursued academic career. Whatever the case, I did not join the audience in enthusiastic applause after professor Jardine had finished. I even regret that I did not stand up and say, as a woman, junior researcher, and, on the top of that, a person coming from Central Europe, that I never felt discriminated within the organisation. And also that I would like to be judged based solely on my academic achievements, rather than other qualities such as gender or perhaps yet other.

While the two events described above have seemingly little in common, they are both interesting as case studies of how politics pervade areas where one would rather expect to find a shelter from it.

sobota, 30 sierpnia 2014

La bohème (wersja polska poniżej)

Fairly recently, I watched in a Krakow cinema Puccini’s La bohème, broadcasted from the MET. Thanks to the subtitles, I was for the first time able to follow the actual dialogues. The opening scene is set at a cold attic which the main character, Rodolfo, is about to heat with his own theatre play, that is – the paper on which it was written. ‘Sorry, my dear audience, hard times call for great sacrifice’ – he says. His roommates comment, while watching flames that consume subsequent acts: ‘It’s great, full of life – but too short’, ‘There’s nothing lasting about your drama’ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntg9vXxAia8/ - here La bohème with English subtitles). Listening to these lines, I laughed louder than anybody else in the cinema, being a classic embarrassing companion to people who were out with me. I just knew it so well: that was about us, PhD students in the humanities! From then on, I started to call them/us – la bohème. We are poor, but we still prefer our chosen, independent way of life to finding a stable employment elsewhere. We as well sit around with bright people sharing good jokes about our own condition, this being sometimes the only way to distance ourselves from the harsh realities of life.

And it’s even more profound. I can’t quote here any statistical evidence, but certainly my observation shows that there are far less married couples among PhD students than in other groups of the same age. Also, graduate students have way less children than his peers who don’t pursue academic career. Even conservatively minded people who do PhD are part of this tendency. And nobody gets a loan because nobody would be eligible for one. But it’s not only about money – I find that highly sensitive and highly reflective people have it, for better or worse, just harder to settle. And these are precisely the kind of people who often decide to do PhD in the humanities.

piątek, 18 lipca 2014

What good are the humanities? – another attempt at answering an eternal question – part 2 (wersja polska poniżej)

Here is another set of arguments in favour of the humanities. In my last post, I wrote about the very subject of the humanities, that is – the human creation. Its worth makes also knowledge and investigation thereof worthwhile. Today, I am going to write about positive ‘side-effects’ of such activity.

The polemicists expressing their disapproval for the humanities represent most of the time a clearly defined yet often in a way subconsciously adopted ideological stance: one based on utilitarianism and materialism (‘How will you make a living?’, ‘Why should taxpayer’s money be wasted on such things?’, ‘What specific measureable benefits will it bring anybody?’) with its quantitative approach (‘At best, only few specialists will read your article’). Certainty of some such judgements suggests that they are often seen as dogmas rather than just opinions, ones of many, only particularly wide-spread nowadays.  

Values such as truth, goodness and beauty may be set against materialism and utilitarianism; this kind of alternative attitude is presented not only in the Bible teachings, but also in the major part of European philosophy. Also, it can be easily noticed that the quantitative criterion brings poor results when applied to cultural activity. The degradation of popular culture which we witnessed in Poland after free market economy had been introduced would form here a good example (of course free market doesn’t exclude good culture, but in this particular case the negative co-incidence seems quite obvious). A never-ending soap opera is emblematic of this new reality – the characters can only talk about their feelings and everyday life. Everything else – slightly more intelligent jokes, alluding to history or politics, distinct opinions, presenting experience different than that of painstakingly average people – might result in decreased numbers of viewers, who would be exposed to not getting something. The news are now produced in a similar fashion: they contain almost no informative content, the aim of them being primarily to trigger in the spectator shallow compassion and thoughtless laughter.

The very presence of the humanists in the society reminds of values different than commonly taken for granted. And it’s not just about some empty declarations – a humanist patiently chooses a salary that is comparatively low and hard to get (I’m talking here about current employment reduction at the universities and high competitiveness in applying for research grants) and does so only to commit to a ‘useless’ activity. Thus, he continually undermines the above-described dogma. His work reminds us also of variety of human talents, which, for common good, should develop naturally, rather than be suppressed by a stereotypical idea of a ‘decent job’. Saint Paul gives, in my opinion, the best description of different ‘gifts’ in his I Epistle to the Corinthians. Today, his rhetorical questions (1 Cor. 12, 29) could be replaced by some other ones, like: ‘Are all doctors? Are all businessmen? Should everybody study law? Should everybody start up a charity?’

The most conspicuous effect of this largely anti-materialistic choice made by humanists is teaching students. PhD candidates are not paid for didactic work they do. Nonetheless, they often invest a lot of commitment in it – all in good cause. This intellectual formation of students wouldn’t be successful, if the teachers didn’t occupy themselves primarily with thinking, reading and writing. Teaching and learning have to go hand in hand.

I’m writing here, of course, about some ideal of humanists’ activity. But just as charlatans shouldn’t make us doubt the importance of medicine, harmful as they are, so the existence of unwise humanists wouldn’t be a sufficient reason to reject all the humanities.

This book tells the story of people saving cultural property during WWII - their attitude should be a model for today's humanists

środa, 9 lipca 2014

What good are the humanities? – another attempt at answering an eternal question – part 1 (wersja polska poniżej)

„Humanities departments cause only increased unemployment”, „And how will you make a living?”, „Do you want to teach children at school?”, „It’s useless”, „It must be quite pleasant to spend your life reading old books at the taxpayer’s expense” etc. Depending on the stage in his life, a humanist is faced with each of these remarks to various extent: if he earns no money yet – then he should think about his future unemployment (statement 1–2), or at best be prepared for taking a highly unattractive post (statement 3). If he already gets a small salary for what he does – then he is a parasite, living from decent work of other taxpayers (statements 4–5).

San Diego, 2013. The conference was taking place here, but I spent the taxpayer's money at one of the cheapest hostels in town.
 
Being a humanist who currently gets a small salary for her work, I will focus on the two latter charges. Answering them never seemed an easy task to me. Actually, I spent a year off my graduate studies working full-time for a charity, one of main motifs for this decision being my constant worry that the work in the academia, which I had undertaken, seemed useless and impractical. After being hugely disappointed by this charitable institution, but also thanks to better recognition of my natural inclinations, I decided to return to the university. But I still had no strong conviction that research work is important. For some time, I considered it to be a kind of entertainment, maybe a slightly more dignified one: ‘If people find pleasure in watching soap operas, why shouldn’t they enjoy listening to or delivering an interesting presentation at a conference?’ Now I think that, after all, the humanities mean more than sheer entertainment. But I hope that the story of my uncertainty in this matter will make the following argumentation more convincing.

Only very few people, I suppose, would agree with a statement that all cultural activity is useless. On average, the critics of the humanities have in mind only some part of culture, a part particularly useless according to them. The scope of ‘uselessness’ is limited in such polemics in a number of ways. Some suggest that useless are humanists dealing with earlier cultures, which can be seen as antiquated and out-of-date. Some claim that only really good culture is worth some attention, unlike the mediocre one (often an argument ad Shakesperium is raised in this context – ‘I’d understand if you wrote on, say, Shakespeare, but...’). Some agree that art is useful, because it can give people pleasure, yet investigating it has little sense indeed – this latter activity was invented for and by frustrated people, who themselves were not talented enough to become artists.

So let’s take these arguments one at a time. Culture cannot be judged as better or worse sole criterion of such judgement being era in which this culture was created. This kind of thinking is based on simplistic progressivism, which is quite easy to refute. People who lived five centuries or three thousand years ago were also people (see quote from Józef Mackiewicz here) and I see no reason why we should discriminate against knowledge and wisdom they shared. It seems impossible to decide who has ‘less’ to offer to us: Homer, Tolstoj or Picasso. I couldn’t possibly imagine human culture without any of them.

Also, the argument saying that some part of culture is more worth-while based on its quality seems tricky. For it is often the case that only intense studies and considerable commitment of humanists allow to single out these highest achievements of mankind, and this still with all sorts of different reservations. Experts are needed to identify an unknown painting found in an attic as a van Gogh’s masterpiece or to retrieve Norwid’s poems from decades of oblivion. Besides, the question about quality is simply not the only interesting question which can be posed by humanists in their research.

And finally: it was often scholars (in a very broad sense of the word), not only artists, who enabled culture to be passed down to future generations. No one I talked to about these topics supports, I hope, burning cultural property we (as mankind) witnessed during, let’s say, WWII. And it wouldn’t be wise to assume that something similar won’t happen again. Not only the history of 20th century but also the whole known history proves that a gigantic effort of past generations – from working in medieval scriptoria to creating digital databases – was enough to save only some fraction of all culture from turmoil of wars and other catastrophes.

niedziela, 25 maja 2014

Teamwork - sensu lato (wersja polska poniżej)

Mentoring – this is the most common kind of relationship at the Polish humanities departments. We are used to it and we can handle it with ease. But conducting a research project offers sometimes the first opportunity to work in a different way – in a team of colleagues.

In my project, both of these relationships are present – this most familiar, between the junior researchers and their mentor, professor Janusz Stanisław Gruchała, and this entirely new one – with Iwona Grabska-Gradzińska, who helps me with creating a database to gather in it information on prints from Oels and whose patience for my incompetence in the field of digital humanities is just as broad as is this very incompetence. We both are currently preparing doctoral theses at the Institute of Editorial Studies, Jagiellonian University. This experience of co-working with a fellow student, though in a two-person team only, is quite special and totally valuable. Thanks to it, one can learn, apart from matters strictly academic, how to talk „business” – what is needed has to be clearly communicated; one has to plan actions which would be doable, sensible and beneficial for everybody involved. These seemingly obvious matters are a novelty indeed for someone who for months is organizing their work according to totally individualistic rules agreed on with nobody else but himself. Leaving this comfort zone seems a good idea in every respect. If we think for a brief moment about the meaning of the word ‘humanities’ then one shall name it a paradox indeed that the scientists outstrip humanists in undertaking teamwork, which actually means ‘work with another human being’.

But generally, the humanities couldn’t prosper properly, as could probably no other human activity, without even more broadly understood, simple and selfless kindness of others. ‘The acknowledgements’, probably the most omitted part of scholarly publications, mean more than sheer courtesy – this knows anybody who tried to do anything of academic quality. One just can’t make it on their own. It became fully clear to me already in the first two weeks of conducting my project. During this short time, I talked to Dr. Jacek Partyka, Dr. Klaudia Socha, Kasia Płaszczyńska-Herman and Tomek Nastulczyk about searching library catalogues, catologuing old printed books and preparing a database. My project wouldn’t have properly started without these conversations, or, in the best-case scenario, it would have been a misfire. And the very writing of a grant application? The number of people to whom I am deeply indebted is great indeed. Professor Janusz Gruchała advised me on preparing a project estimate and structuring work plan. Professor Andrzej Borowski expressed his warm encouragement when I first mentioned the idea on his seminar. My dad corrected the English version, my sister became an advisor with regards to all formal matters. The project was talked over with my friends – Stijn van Rossem, Kasia Płaszczyńska-Herman, Andrzej Probulski (please, forgive me, if I forgot to mention anybody involved). Finally, ms Katarzyna Pilipowicz, who was responsible for submitting the applications, responded to all inquiries and cared for all formal details with friendliness, warmth, patience and a smile so rare in similar institutions.

So, Erasmus of Rotterdam was right when he said:

Adeo nihil est in rebus humanis, quod ipsum sibi sufficiat. In ipsis statim vitae primordiis perisset hominum genus, nisi conditum propagasset coniugalis concordia; nec enim nasceretur homo et mox natus interiret atque in ipso vitae limine vitam amitteret, nisi obstetricum amica manus, nisi nutricum amica pietas succurreret infantulo. Atque in hunc vsum vehementissimos illos pietatis igniculos inseuit, vt parentes etiam illud ament, quod nondum viderunt. Adiecit mutuam liberorum erga parentes pietatem, vt illorum imbecillitas horum praesidiis vicissim subleuaretur, fieretque illa cunctis quidem ex aequo plausibilis, sed Graecis aptissime dicta ἀντιπελάργωσις. Accedunt huc cognationum et affinitatum vincula, accedit in nonnullis ingeniorum, studiorum formaeque similitudo, certissima beneuolentiae conciliatrix, in multis arcanus quidam animorum sensus ac mirus ad mutuum amorem stimulus, quem veteres admirati numini ascribebant (Erasmus Roterodamus, Querela pacis, ed. O. Herding, in: Opera omnia, Ord. 4, T. 2, Amsterdam 1977, s. 64.).

My translation to English would give such injustice to this passage that I am forced to refer dear reader to the text in Collected Works of Erasmus edition. But the first sentence is most important here: ‘So, there is nothing in human affairs which would be self-sufficient’.